The Best Sump Pumps 2017 – Reviews and Recommendations

Your sump pump is more than just some nondescript basement-dwelling motor. It’s the difference between a flooded basement with water problems and a dry, clean basement. When your sump pump fails to operate correctly, a myriad of problems can occur. The first result of a faulty sump pump is a wet basement. The problems don’t end there.

the best sump pumps

Water in your basement leads to mold, which is dangerous for you and your family. Mold is also very expensive to get rid of and it may include a total refinishing of your basement, not to mention other problems water can create within your house like rotting wood, rotting drywall and electrical safety issues.

If your sump pump has failed to keep your basement dry, you need to get it replaced ASAP.

We’ve broken up our sump pump reviews into two sections below – sump pumps with a battery backup and sump pumps without a battery backup.

If you’ve never had a battery backup before, you definitely should consider investing in one. A battery backup will turn on if your main sump pump stops working or if it loses power as a result of a power outage. From my personal experience, it is well worth the extra money to buy a sump pump with battery backup.

Sump pumps range in price from as little as $70 to over $400 for fully-featured, powerful battery-backup models. We’ve broken down our list of the best sump pumps on the market below.

The Best Sump Pumps With Battery Backup

WAYNE WSS30V Pre-Assembled 120/12V 1/2 HP Primary and Battery Backup

Assembled in the USA, though the parts might come from a mix of places. This system is big, so your sump basin needs to be at least 15 inches wide to keep everything working properly. This is a big ½ HP pump that will put out up to 4200 gallons per hour, it’s constructed of tough cast iron, and has a fenced top-suction system to keep everything neat, clean, and working. Normally, the system runs on 120 volts. But the battery backup system is set up to hand either a 40 amp-hour or 75 amp-hour deep cycle battery to keep it running when the power goes out. If you would like to get your own battery separately, you can purchase just the pump. The system includes a five year warranty, so no worries about it dying on you.

Basement Watchdog BWE Emergency Back-Up Sump Pump

Designed as a backup pump, this little guy will actually work fairly well in it’s own right. The setup doesn’t come with a battery, so you will need to supply your own deep cycle, but everything else you need is in the kit. A control panel will light up and tell you what kind of maintenance is required. The kit includes a controller, charger, float switch, pump, and battery box. The pump itself is quite a little performer, a one horsepower pump, even though the flow specs don’t show it being super efficient. Maximum flow rate is 2000 gallons per hour. If you are looking for a simple solution for a basement or crawlspace sump, it should do the trick.

Zoeller 508-0006 Aquanot 508 Sump Pump

The whole kit and kaboodle. This system is built tough, by the quality manufacturer Zoeller, so you can expect it to last a long time. The Model 53 12-volt pump backs up the primary 508, which puts out over 2500 gallons per hour. The system comes with a check valve, float switch, and piping. It also comes with a solid-state 10 amp battery recharging system, complete with lights, indicators, and alarms. 12 volt battery not included.

Everything comes pre-assembled in the box, and setup couldn’t be simpler, as long as you have a large enough place for it. Ideally, the whole unit should be below ground level, including the backup, for it to keep working properly.

Basement Watchdog BW4000 1730 Gallons Per Hour Combination

A slightly more compact pre-assembled kit with a much smaller footprint than the others. The package contains an electric controller, charger, and two dual micro reed float switches, primary and backup pump, and instruction manual. Just add battery. The compact pump will fit in a 12 inch hole, and the back-up is equipped with monitoring systems to diagnose problems, including an alarm buzzer.

Maximum output is 1730 gallons per hour, so it’s not a super heavy-duty solution, but more than enough for most basements. The primary will chuck a respectable 3200 gallons per hour when connected to AC power. The whole setup is fairly light as well, weighing in at just 26 pounds, and will run off a normal 110 outlet. The pump also comes with a two year warranty.

The Best Standalone Sump Pumps w/ No Battery Backup

Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump

Enough power to lift water up to 25 vertical feet makes this small and affordable submersible pump incredibly affordable. Constructed of corrosion resisting thermoplastic, and backed by a one year warranty. One piece motor construction, double seals, and solid copper wiring make this little pump solid and built to last, tested to the highest standards.

At ground level it will crank out 30 gallons per minute. It also has a removable screen on the bottom for easy cleaning, and the wide intake area ensures that it won’t clog up on you. There’s no automatic shut off, so it’s designed to be controlled manually.

Don’t fall for the “get what you pay for” stuff on this one, this pump will last at least as long as pumps two or three times the price.

WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Submersible Cast Iron and Stainless Steel Sump Pump

If you need a submersible pump for frequently flooding areas, like crawlspaces or drainages, this pump from Wayne comes with it’s own float, and it’s ready to tackle your problem. Maximum flow rate is just over 75 gallons per minute. The top suction design minimizes air locks and clogging, and the stainless steel motor is housed in a cast iron base.

The ¾ horsepower motor will keep it running strong. You will need at least an 11-inch diameter pit, as this is a large unit meant for serious performance. It even comes with a five year warranty. Talk about a company that believes in their product. The pump will still put out almost 60 gallons per minute with ten feet of lift.

Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump, 1/3 Hp

A solid, enameled cast iron case makes this a monster of a pump, even for only having a third of a horsepower. The little monster weighs about twenty-one pounds, and it’s engineered with a thermoplastic base and a cast iron switch attached to the float. For such a low power option, you might not expect it to push 45 gallons per minute but it does, just don’t expect it to pass a vertical height of much more than 15 feet.

The sturdy construction is so rugged that it could survive just about anything, unless the float gets stuck and the motor burns up. It comes with a three year warranty, and Zoeller has a catalog of parts, so if you wanted to, you could actually rebuild the whole pump. That’s a design feature that you don’t see enough of these days.

XtremePower 1 HP Stainless Steel Submersible Pump

It might not have the flow rates that the bigger guys have, but this little 1 horse is designed to go deep, pulling suction from up to 28 feet. It comes with a 26’ cord to make sure that you can get it way down deep where you need it. Accepts either 1 inch or 1-14 inch discharge fittings. The flow rate is solid, around 3000 gallons per hour, or 50 gallons per minute at ground level.

So while it isn’t the fastest pumping 1 horsepower motor, it should still drain your backyard pool in a few hours, and it’s solid enough to hold up in the process. The stainless steel construction makes it pretty resistant to most forms of corrosion as well. And you can’t hardly beat the price if this little pump meets your needs.

What To Look For in a Good Sump Pump for Your Basement

Sump pumps can sometimes fail, especially after years of storms and pumping water out of your basement. In fact, that’s the reason why you’ve come to this site – to get help in finding a reliable sump pump to replace your old one.

Not all sump pumps are created equal and some definitely have some advantages over others. For example, you might be surprised that sump pump horsepower ratings are not all created equal and a lesser 2hp sump pump won’t necessarily outperform or last as long as a quality 1hp model.

So what do you look for in a sump pump? Well the first thing to look at is construction. Many sump pumps fail when the float (the part that lets the sump pump’s motor know it’s time to start pumping water) fails to operate or function as it should. This can be due to several reasons but the main factor are the materials being used. A flimsy thin plastic float just isn’t going to stand the time compared to a beefier counterpart.

Many sump pump manufacturers cut costs by using a large percentage of plastic parts in their construction. A good way to tell a high-quality sump pump from it’s lesser counterparts is the weight. The fact is, good sump pumps are heavy! Trusted sump pump brands use high quality materials in their pumps and you’ll know this when you compare prices of sump pumps.

Don’t settle for a cheap sump pump. Afterall, it’s the only thing that’s stopping your sump well from overflowing and damaging your possessions stored in your basement.

If you have a finished basement, we very highly recommend sump pumps with battery backups. The battery backup is essentially another pump that activates when it senses that your primary pump has failed. Sure, sump pumps with battery backups can be expensive – even costing as much as $500 for a complete setup, but that’s beans compared to the amount of damage a wet basement can cause, not to mention the health hazards of mold in your basement.

Here’s a summary of what you should be looking for in a quality sump pump:

  1. High quality materials and metal rather than lots of plastic parts
  2. Weight – this is a key indicator of the best sump pumps
  3. Higher price – you’ll pay a little extra now vs. cheaper pumps that will fail in a few years
  4. Horsepower isn’t everything – go for a good quality sump pump with lesser HP rating vs the cheapo high-horsepower model

Recommended Sump Pump Manufacturers

Here are some of the most popular sump pump manufacturers that product quality products that last.